Request for comments/Promote Robin1020th as bureaucrat.

As you all may know, I have over 9.000 edits made and always online trying to improve all the flaws the previous wikis failed, so I am asking, should Robin be Bureaucrat (aka leader) and take it over from here or not.

Support

1.  Support This should be obvious. Szczypak 64 21:26, November 01 2023 (GMT+2)
2.  Support Same as above ChessGuy66 (talk) 20:27, November 1, 2023 (UTC)
3.  Support Even if this is about me, i don't see a reason i should not be able to vote. Robin (talk) 20:27, November 1, 2023 (UTC)
4.  Support This is a great idea. NewMarioBobFan (talk) 21:23, November 1, 2023 (UTC)
5.  Support I don't see why not. :) Batboy234 21:26 November 1, 2023 (UTC)
6.  Support So far, he eliminated trolls with dumb porn pages which is a good move for an admin. KENNY STEWART 6284 (talk) 10:10 November 5, 2023 (UTC)

Oppose

1.  Oppose While he's good enough to be an admin, aside from a few flaws that I want him to fix, I don't think he's responsible enough to be a bureaucrat. One of the few reasons being too open to criticism, and while listening to criticism is a good thing, he listens to EVERY type of criticism, even invalid ones. Plus, while your grammar is better than ChessGuy, it's still eh, and by the time I write this, I fixed some of your grammar errors. CJWorldGame32125 (talk) 21:07, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

hold on i thought i fairly improved my grammar? ChessGuy66 (talk) 21:04, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

Your grammar errors are right there. CJWorldGame32125 (talk) 21:07, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

where?ChessGuy66 (talk) 21:08, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

Well i don't see how "being too open to criticism" is a bad thing, also no one is perfect at grammar even yours has some flaws, and even if i made some mistakes i will fix it soon enough. Robin (talk)

Well, about grammar, you're right, neither I am perfect in grammar, but the criticism thing is something worth following. Even Tali will tell you that following every kind of criticism (such nasty and invalid) is bad. CJWorldGame32125 (talk) 21:15, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

I’m sorry for all this immature stuff I did by attempting to blacklist review sites and constantly removing cheeseguy17’s pointers.ChessGuy66 (talk) 21:21, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

Is that so? Well in that case what are the few nasty criticism i shouldn't have followed? Robin (talk)

Yep ChessGuy66 (talk) 21:25, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

Also isn't the not being open to criticism the reason why the previous wiki failed and shut down? This is the reason i am too open, so that this wiki will never shut down, there is also the alternative wikis of these on fandom, (but i am sure not all people are online there very often, not to mention some of poorly made pages the original wikis had are still there without trying to improve it, so i went on and imported all the fixes there, i just wish i could be an admin there too to improve it further more).

Robin (talk)

I'm not saying you shouldn't listen to criticism, in fact you should, everyone should, what I am saying is that you shouldn't (how can I say nicely, "mindlessly"?) follow criticism, because some criticism is straight up invalid or wrong. CJWorldGame32125 (talk) 23:13, November 1, 2023 (UTC)

Well than name all the criticism that shouldn't have been followed. Robin (talk)

ChessGuy's requests like undeleting the NBA 2K24 page, restoring thee Caution template despite the Mature template already existing, refusing to read SuperStreetKombat's constructive criticism about the template because it was too long, which felt embarassing, because you should read constructive criticism, even if it was too long.

Well i didn't know the game was entirely hated, i dont remember restoring the template and if i did, i didn't know what it was about, i actually did read it, i just asked him to read it shortly and it's not embarrasing. Also there are already 6 supports (5 if not counting the proposer) and only one opposing. Robin (talk)

Well, actually I realized that despite low user ratings on MetaCrtic and Steam, I realized the community (like the content creators and stuff) had mixed feelings on this game. But, I still won’t try to make 2K24 in a positive perspective, but still.ChessGuy66 (talk) 14:46, November 5, 2023 (UTC)

Comments

Loading comments...